What the piece has to do
Before you design anything

What to settle before you design: what the piece has to do, and where it has to do it

Two facts settle most of what follows: what one person should be able to do after seeing the piece, and how far away they will be standing when they see it.

Start here Essentials

Before any of this is a design problem, it is four questions. They take twenty minutes and a pair of shoes, and they decide more about whether the piece works than anything you will do later.

  1. Write what one person should be able to do after seeing it. One sentence, beginning "After seeing this, one person will" (the one action).
  2. Go and stand where it will be read, and pace off the distance. Count your steps from where a reader will be to where the piece will be, and write the number down (the distance).
  3. Write down the facts that person needs in order to do it. Not everything true about the event: the things somebody cannot act without (the facts).
  4. Decide the finished size and how many you need. These two decide what a printer can do for you and what it costs (size and quantity).

Minimum time: about 20 minutes, most of it walking. Done when: you have one sentence beginning "After seeing this, one person will", a distance in feet that you paced yourself, and a written list of the facts.

1. The order the decisions have to come in Understand

Most everyday pieces fail before anyone chooses a font. Someone opens a template and starts picking colors without having settled what the piece has to get done, who reads it, from how far away, and what one thing a reader has to be able to do afterward. By the time the font is chosen, the date is at 10 point and the address is missing.

That is not a failure of taste. It is a failure of order. The decisions in this manual are ordinary and most of them are small, but they only work in a sequence, because each one needs an answer from the one before it. You cannot size the headline until you know how far away it is read. You cannot know what goes largest until you know what the piece is for. You cannot decide whether a picture earns its place until you know what the words are.

So here is the order the rest of this manual follows, and this chapter is the first step of it:

  1. What the piece has to do, and where it has to do it. The one action, the distance, the situation.
  2. The words, cut to what a reader needs, with every checkable fact checked. That is The words come first.
  3. Four decisions that settle whether it works, whatever it is: what gets read first, the type, the space, the contrast.
  4. What you put in it: pictures you are allowed to use, drawings you make yourself.
  5. The particular object: a flyer, an invitation, a sign, a deck.

Preference The order above is this manual's, not a published standard. What makes it worth following is that each step produces something the next step needs, and the two things this chapter produces, the action and the distance, are needed by almost everything after it.

There is one more reason to do this part on paper rather than on a screen. A design tool opens on a template, and a template is an answer to a question nobody has asked yet. The brief is the question.

2. The one action, written as a sentence

Write a sentence that begins "After seeing this, one person will". Finish it with something a person does, in the world, with their body or their phone or their calendar.

Not an actionAn action
Raise awareness of the marketCome to the Arbor Street lot on the second Saturday morning
Let people know about story hourBring a child to the Oak Room on a Thursday at 10:30
Advertise the saleTurn left at the corner and stop at the house with the sale
Invite people to the supperCall Marguerite by March 1 and say yes
Explain the culvert problemVote to put the culvert survey on the spring agenda

The left column gives you nothing to design with. It has no size, no date, no place to stand. The right column tells you immediately what has to be biggest, what has to be legible at what distance, and which fact a reader cannot act without. "Call Marguerite by March 1" tells you that a phone number and a date are load bearing and that a photograph of the honoree is not.

Write one sentence. If you find yourself writing three, you have either three pieces or one piece with a problem, and it is worth knowing which before you start.

Limits

A reader will over-read "know the one action" into "put only one thing on it". The one action decides what goes largest. It does not decide what else goes on the piece. A flyer that is beautiful and does not say the end time has failed at its job, not at its design. The next section is the list of things somebody cannot act without, and that list is usually longer than the people cutting words expect.

3. The distance, paced

Go to the place. Stand where a reader will actually be standing. Walk to where the piece will actually be, counting your steps, and write the number down.

Test it An adult's ordinary walking pace is roughly two and a half to three feet, so counting steps and multiplying by three gives a usable figure in a minute. What matters is that the number came from your feet rather than from a guess made at a desk, because a guess made at a desk usually comes out short. The eye is bad at judging distance across a parking lot and worse through a shop window.

Three things make the paced number different from the one you would guess:

  • Where people stop. The distance that counts is from the nearest point a reader can get to, not from where you are standing when you hang it. For a flyer in a shop window, that is the sidewalk, not the inside of the glass. The 2010 ADA Standards define viewing distance for signs in their scope the same way: the horizontal distance between the character and whatever stops a reader from coming closer. Regulation
  • How fast they are moving. Somebody walking past a board has a few seconds. Somebody driving past a corner at 25 miles an hour has about a second and a half of useful warning in sixty feet of approach, which is why a yard sign carries one message.
  • What is in the way. Glass, glare, a parked truck, forty other flyers. The distance is the start of the question and the situation is the rest of it.

Write the paced number on the brief. Letter height from distance turns it into a capital-letter height, and What gets read first uses it to decide what belongs in level one.

4. The situation it will be read in

Distance is one number. The situation is everything else about the moment of reading, and three questions get most of it:

  1. What else is competing? A community board with forty flyers on it is a different problem from an empty hallway wall. On the board, the top inch and a half of your flyer may be all that is visible, because the flyers pinned over it cover the rest.
  2. How long do they have? Standing at a bulletin board: five or ten seconds, and they are choosing whether to spend more. Driving: one or two seconds. Sitting in a hall holding an invitation: as long as they want, which changes the job completely.
  3. What is the light? A hallway sign under fluorescent light, a window flyer in afternoon glare, a projected slide in a lit council chamber, a card read at a kitchen table. Contrast and color has the measurable part of this, and the part the measurement does not cover.

The Nielsen Norman Group's eye-tracking work on text scanning is the closest thing to evidence this manual has about what people do with a page they have not committed to reading. Its 2017 article on the F-shaped pattern is careful about the conditions: the pattern shows up when text has little or no formatting, when the reader is trying to be efficient, and when the reader is not committed enough to read every word. Test it The useful part is its own conclusion, which is that headings, bullets and bold text are the antidotes rather than the problem. A reader skimming an unformatted block falls back on scanning the left edge. A reader given headings that say something scans the headings instead.

Go deeper

The 2019 follow-up, Text Scanning Patterns, names the other patterns and ranks them: F-pattern, spotted, layer-cake and commitment, which it calls worst to best for effectiveness. The layer-cake pattern, where a reader scans headings and drops into the one that matters, is the one it calls by far the most effective way to scan short of reading nearly every word.

Two cautions about using this. The heatmaps in the article come from small groups, 45, 47 and six users in the examples it shows, and are illustrations rather than statistical tests. And the article says plainly that patterns are highly contingent on the task, the reader's assumptions, the layout and the content type. So the honest form of the claim is: Test it if your piece has headings that say something, readers who are skimming have something to skim; if it does not, they will fall back on the edges. That is a reason to write real headings, not a law about eyeballs.

5. The facts that let somebody act

Now write the list. One fact a line, no sentences yet. The test for each line is not "is this true" but "can somebody complete the action without it".

The lines people leave off, in rough order of how often it happens:

  • The end time. A flyer that says the market starts at 8 and not that it closes at 1 sends somebody at 12:45.
  • The cost, and how it is paid. Free is a fact worth printing. So is eighteen dollars at the door, because that is the difference between bringing a wallet and not.
  • Where to park, or that there is no parking.
  • Whether children are welcome, or whether it is for children.
  • Whether to bring something. A dish, a chair, a bag, a check.
  • The room, not just the building. A library has a building sign already. What a family needs is the Oak Room.
  • Who to ask, and how. A name and one way to reach them.
  • The day of the week beside the date. It is redundant, and it is the redundancy that catches a typo.

Most of those are short. A fact is cheap in space and expensive in its absence, which is the opposite of the way people usually cut. What is expensive in space is explanation: the paragraph about why the market was founded, the sentence about how much the committee has enjoyed planning the supper. Those are the words to cut, and The words come first is the chapter that does the cutting.

Put the list on the Facts to check sheet in The piece plan. It starts with ten rows waiting for you, and the column beside each one is for what you checked it against.

6. Finished size and how many

Two more numbers, and they are mostly decided by the answers above plus what you can get printed.

PieceCommon finished sizesWhat decides it
Flyer for a board or a window8.5 by 11 inAny home printer and any copy shop does it without an argument
Small poster11 by 17 inA copy shop; most home printers stop at letter or legal
Poster18 by 24 in, 24 by 36 inA print service; the reading distance usually drove you here
Mailed card4 by 6 in, 5 by 7 inPostal dimensions and envelope sizes, in Invitations and mailed cards
Yard or corner signMeasure the frame you boughtNo published standard sets a size; the wire frame does
SlidesWidescreen or 4:3The projector in the room, which you ask about

Convention Those paper sizes are the conventional US figures, taken from a reference site rather than from the underlying standards documents, which this manual did not read. The full table, with what each source is, is on The numbers, and where each comes from.

Quantity matters more than it looks, because it changes who prints it. Sixty flyers with color to the edge is a copy shop job. Three signs is a home printer and some tape, or a sign shop if they have to survive weather. The arithmetic for what the printer needs is in Page setup and resolution, and the thing to settle today is simply the two numbers.

Two audiences, two distances Go deeper

Sometimes one piece is read at two distances. A flyer in a shop window is seen from the sidewalk at six or eight feet by people walking past, and from a foot away by the person who stopped. A sandwich board at a lot gate is read at fifteen feet by someone deciding whether to turn in, and at three feet by someone already standing at it.

The workable answer is to design two zones rather than to average the two distances. The top zone carries the level-one line, sized for the far distance, and it has to work with nothing else read. The lower zone carries the facts, sized for arm's length, and it is allowed to be invisible from across the street. Averaging produces a piece that is too small to catch anybody and too large to hold the facts.

Two audiences is a harder case than two distances, and the honest answer is often that it is two pieces. A flyer that has to recruit volunteers and invite guests is doing two jobs with two actions, and one of them will be undersold. If you cannot split it, decide which action is the real one, give it the top of the piece, and give the other one a line at the bottom.

And sometimes the answer is that a piece is not needed. If the audience is eleven people whose phone numbers you have, a flyer is slower, costs money and reaches fewer of them than eleven text messages. The reason to notice this is not thrift. It is that a piece made because a piece is what one makes tends to have no action in it, which is the failure this whole chapter is about.

7. See it: four briefs, four different pieces See it

Fictional example

Dolores Reyes and the Arbor Street Market. A monthly producers' market in the Arbor Street municipal lot, second Saturday of the month, 8:00 AM to 1:00 PM, free to attend, fourteen vendors. Dolores needs three pieces, and the brief is different for each.

Known. The flyers go in shop windows and are read from the sidewalk; she paced it at about six feet. The entrance signs are read from a car moving slowly into the lot, which she paced along the approach at about forty feet. The sandwich board stands at the lot gate and is read at about fifteen feet. She needs sixty flyers, two signs and one board. Flyers at a copy shop, signs at a sign shop. She works in Canva on the free plan.

Assumed. That the shopkeepers will put the flyers where she asks, in the window rather than on a counter. That is Dolores's assumption, and it changes the distance from six feet to two if she is wrong. She can settle it by asking one shopkeeper before printing sixty.

Open. Whether the lot's owner, the municipality, allows a sandwich board at the gate, and whether the entrance signs need a permit. Settled by: the municipal clerk, whom Dolores calls. This manual names no rule for any place.

The one action, per piece. Flyer: "After seeing this, one person will put the second Saturday in their calendar." Entrance sign: "After seeing this, one driver will turn into this lot." Sandwich board: "After seeing this, one person on the sidewalk will walk in."

Fictional example

Wendell Halvorsen's driveway sale. Saturday, 8:00 AM to 2:00 PM, 1409 Vance Street. Three signs on 12 by 18 inch posterboard: one zip-tied to his own fence, two on posts at the corners of Vance and Pell. Made in Microsoft Word, printed at home on 8.5 by 11 inch paper and taped to board.

Known. The corner signs are read from a car at about twenty-five miles an hour, with roughly sixty feet of warning, which Wendell paced along the curb. That is the whole brief: one action, one distance, two facts.

Assumed. That drivers are looking for the sign. They are not; they are driving. Test it Wendell can check this by having somebody drive him past at the real speed.

Open. Whether a sign may stand at that corner, and for how long. Settled by: his municipal clerk or code office.

The one action. "After seeing this, one driver will turn onto Vance and look for the house with the sale." Which tells him that an arrow is doing more work than the street number, and that the date and time belong on the fence sign at the house rather than on the corner signs, where nobody can read them anyway.

8. Practice: write the brief Practice

Minimum: the one-sentence action and a paced distance, written down. That is enough to carry into every other chapter. Time: about 30 minutes, including the walk. Materials: paper and a pen, shoes, and the place the piece will live.

  1. Write the action sentence first, before you go anywhere. "After seeing this, one person will..." If you cannot finish it, write down what you are unsure about; that is a real finding and it is better found now.
  2. Go to the place. Stand where a reader stands. Pace to where the piece will be. Write the number of steps and the number of feet.
  3. While you are there, look at what the piece is competing with. Photograph the board, the window, the hallway, the corner. You will want it when you are deciding what has to be in level one.
  4. Write the facts, one a line. Then go down the list and cross out anything somebody could complete the action without. Keep the crossed-out list; The words come first asks you to look at it again.
  5. Open The piece plan and fill in the brief sheet. Nine lines. Write "to decide" where you have not decided.
Go deeper

Two extra passes, worth it on anything that costs money to print.

The stranger test. Hand your fact list to somebody who knows nothing about the event and ask them to tell you what they would do next. The gaps show up immediately, and they are usually the end time, the cost or the room.

The second distance. If your piece is read from two places, pace both and write both on the brief. Then decide which one level one is sized for, and say so on the brief, so the decision is recorded rather than drifting.

9. Your piece Your piece

10. Check your work Check your work

Criteria

  • Does your sentence name something a person does, rather than something they feel or know?
  • Did the distance come from your feet, or from your memory of the place?
  • Could a stranger act on your fact list without asking you a question?
  • Is there one action, or did you write three and keep all of them?
  • Do you know what the piece is competing with where it will live?

Worked example

Wendell's brief is four lines long: turn onto Vance and find the sale; sixty feet, from a car; the facts are an arrow and the word SALE, with the date and time on the fence sign at the house; three signs at 12 by 18 inches, printed at home. Against the criteria: the sentence names a turn, the distance was paced along the curb, a stranger can act on it, and he knows the competing object is the road. The thing he has not settled is whether a sign may stand at that corner, which is on the brief as an open question with the clerk's name beside it, not as a decision.

Common mistakes

  • Writing a goal instead of an action. "Raise the profile of the market" has no size, no date and no reader. Notice it by trying to say who does what.
  • Pacing from the wrong place. Standing inside the shop to measure a window flyer gives you two feet instead of six. Stand where the reader stands.
  • Cutting facts to make it look clean. The end time and the cost are not clutter. Explanation is clutter.
  • Deciding the size from the template that opened. The size follows the distance and the printer, and the template follows the size.
  • Treating a guessed distance as a measured one. The letter height moves by an eighth of an inch for every foot you are out, which at twenty feet of error is two and a half inches of letter.

What is still unresolved

This chapter cannot tell you what to write. It gives you a list of facts and an action; turning those into finished text is The words come first. It cannot tell you how big anything has to be, only the distance that decides it, which Letter height from distance converts. And it cannot tell you whether you are allowed to put the piece where you want to put it. Sign ordinances, posting rules, permit requirements and window permissions vary by place, and this manual names no rule for any place. Ask the owner of the window, the board or the lawn, and ask your municipal clerk about anything on a street.

11. Knowledge check and scenario

Why does the action have to be something a person does, rather than something they know?
Because a thing a person does has a time, a place and a set of facts attached to it, and those are what the piece has to carry. "Know about the market" gives you nothing to size, nothing to put first and no way to tell whether a line is load bearing. "Come to the lot on the second Saturday" tells you that the day, the hours and the location are the three lines nobody can act without.
Your flyer goes in a shop window. You measure six feet from the glass to the middle of the sidewalk. A reader can also stop at the glass and read it from a foot away. Which distance sizes the headline?
The six feet. The headline's job is to reach the person who has not stopped yet; the person at the glass can read anything. Design the top zone for six feet and the lower zone for arm's length, rather than averaging the two into a size that does neither.
Somebody tells you the flyer looks cluttered and you should cut half the text. What do you check before cutting?
Whether each line is a fact somebody needs in order to act, or an explanation. Explanations can go. The end time, the cost, the room and the contact cannot, and cutting them is how a clean-looking flyer sends people to the wrong place at the wrong hour. If it still feels cluttered after the explanations are gone, the problem is the hierarchy and the space, not the number of facts.
(Go deeper) When is the honest answer that no piece is needed?
When the audience is small and reachable directly. Eleven people whose numbers you have are reached faster and more reliably by eleven messages than by a flyer. The reason to ask the question is that a piece made because a piece is what one makes usually has no action in it, which is the thing that makes a piece fail.
You have volunteered to make a sign so that families can find story hour inside a library. You are at your desk with a design tool open and a template chosen. What do you do first?
This is the decision that can wait longest, and taking it first tends to lock in a template whose sizes were chosen for something else. Colors also come with a measurable question attached, which is contrast, and you cannot answer it until you know what the text is and where it is read.
Walking the route is the step that tells you what the sign has to do. It usually turns out to be more than one sign, because a family makes a decision at the front door, another at the stairs and another at the Oak Room, and each one answers the question the last one raised. It also gives you the distance at each point, which sizes the letters.
A reasonable second step, and the list is worth having. The tradeoff is that without the walk you do not know how many pieces you are making or how far away each one is read, so you may cut the list for a single sign and then find you needed three.

Checklist

Records your learning only; it is not a qualification.