Setting type at a size, a width and a spacing people can read
The published ranges for type size, line length and line spacing, which of the familiar typography rules have a source behind them, and what the license of your font allows.
- Start here: the essentials
- Three numbers, and who publishes each one
- Size: 16 pixels, or 10 to 12 points
- Measure: 45 to 90 characters a line
- Line spacing, and the disagreement in the sources
- Choosing a typeface, and what the evidence does not say
- What the license of your font allows
- The rules people repeat, and what is behind them
- All caps, centered and justified
- See it: a card and a flyer, measured
- Practice: count a line, measure the spacing
- Your piece
- Check your work
- Knowledge check and scenario
Start here Essentials
Four settings, each with a published range behind it. They cover body text, the part a reader stands close for. The lines people stand back from are sized in Signs instead.
- Set the body text to at least 16 px on a screen, or 10 to 12 points in print. Larger if your readers need it (size).
- Count the characters on one full line and get the count between 45 and 90. Widen the margin before you shrink the type (measure).
- Set line spacing to at least 1.5 times the type size for anything longer than two lines. As a number, not a named setting (line spacing).
- Use one typeface family and take the hierarchy from weight and size instead of a second face. (choosing a typeface).
Minimum time: about 25 minutes. Done when: one full line of your body text counts between 45 and 90 characters, and you can say out loud what size and what line spacing you set.
1. Three numbers, and who publishes each one Understand
Typography advice is unusually full of confident numbers. Some of them have a published source you can read, some are one practitioner's recommendation, and some are repeated with nothing behind them. This chapter says which is which on every figure, because that is the part that transfers to the next piece you make.
| Figure | Who publishes it | What kind of claim |
|---|---|---|
| Body text at least an effective 16 px | U.S. Web Design System (GSA) | A federal design system's convention |
| Print body text 10 to 12 points | Butterick's Practical Typography | One practitioner's recommendation, no study cited |
| 45 to 90 characters a line, 66 a target for long text | U.S. Web Design System, and Butterick independently | Two publishers agreeing |
| Line height at least 1.5 for long text | U.S. Web Design System | A federal design system's convention |
| Line spacing 120 to 145 percent in print | Butterick | One practitioner's recommendation |
| 1.5 line height as a value a reader may impose | WCAG 2.1, SC 1.4.12 | A standard, about reflowable content |
| "Never use more than two typefaces" | Nobody we could find | Folklore |
| "Sans serif is more readable" | Nobody we could find; NN/g says serif is fine | Folklore |
Two things follow from that table. The first is that where a federal publisher and an independent practitioner give the same number, as they do on the 45-to-90 measure, the number is worth more than either source alone, and this manual states it as a figure. The second is that where only one of them says it, the manual gives the number and says whose it is, and you are free to disagree with a person in a way you are not free to disagree with a measurement.
A reader will over-read a published range into a rule that covers everything. These ranges are for running text read at about arm's length. A sign, a slide and a mailed card are each read at a different distance and none of them is covered by 45 to 90 characters a line. A three-word headline has no measure. A banner read from forty feet has no line spacing problem. Where the distance is the constraint, the chapter you want is Signs and the tool is Letter height from distance.
2. Size: 16 pixels, or 10 to 12 points
The U.S. Web Design System says body text should be at least an effective 16 px, and that smaller and larger sizes should be used sparingly for special purposes. Convention Butterick recommends 10 to 12 points for print body text, 15 to 25 px for the web, and 6 to 8 points on a business card. Preference His stated reason for the print figure is the observation that nearly every book, newspaper and magazine is set smaller than 12 point, which is an observation rather than a study.
Three things about that pair of figures are worth getting straight, because they are where most of the confusion lives.
- Points and pixels are not interchangeable. WCAG's explanation of the contrast criterion gives 1 point as about 1.333 px, which makes 12 points roughly 16 px. That conversion is for deciding which contrast threshold applies, and it is a usable rough bridge between the two scales.
- Point size is not letter size. A point size is the size of the slug the letters sit on, not the height of a letter. Two typefaces at 12 point can look a size apart, because what differs is the x-height, the height of a lowercase x. Physical principle This is why "set it at 12 point" is a weaker instruction than it sounds, and why the only reliable check is to print it and look.
- Older readers and low-vision readers push the floor up, not the method. Nothing in this manual's sources gives a size for those readers; what the sources do is let a reader change the size themselves, which a printed flyer cannot. Ask the authority If you know your audience reads large print, ask somebody in it what works, and treat the published floor as a floor.
Here is the same line at several stated sizes. The captions carry the sizes; the lines are decoration, and because they scale with the text-size setting on this page, what they show is the proportion between the rows rather than any size on paper.
- Thursdays at 10:30 in the Oak Room24 px
- Thursdays at 10:30 in the Oak Room19 px
- Thursdays at 10:30 in the Oak Room16 px, the stated floor for body text
- Thursdays at 10:30 in the Oak Room13 px, below the floor
- Thursdays at 10:30 in the Oak Room10 px
3. Measure: 45 to 90 characters a line
Measure is the width of a column of text, counted in characters rather than inches, because the character count is what the eye experiences and inches are not.
The U.S. Web Design System says most lines of text should be 45 to 90 characters, with 66 as a good target for long texts. Butterick gives the same 45-to-90 range, including spaces, or "between two and three alphabets". Convention Two independent publishers, one federal and one a practitioner, giving the same range is the strongest agreement this manual found anywhere in typography.
What goes wrong at each end:
- Too long, over about 90, and the eye has trouble finding the start of the next line, so readers lose their place or reread a line.
- Too short, under about 45, and the eye jumps back so often that the rhythm breaks up; in justified text it also produces large gaps between words.
Test it Count it rather than estimating it. Paste one full line into Line length and line spacing and it gives you the count and a verdict. Paste it from the finished piece, not from a draft, because the whole point is the line you have.
Fix the margin before you fix the type. Butterick's own instruction is to set the measure with the page margins rather than with paragraph indents, and widening a margin costs you nothing that matters while shrinking the type costs legibility. The U.S. Web Design System also notes that measure and line height trade against each other: text with more space between lines can carry a somewhat longer line.
- Typography: the U.S. Web Design System's page with the measure, the size floor and the line-height figures.
- Line length: Butterick's page, free to read, with the same range stated independently.
4. Line spacing, and the disagreement in the sources
Line spacing is the distance from one baseline to the next, and it is stated as a multiple of the type size. The U.S. Web Design System's typesetting page puts it plainly: line height is a unitless multiplier of the font size, so 2 on 16 px text gives 32 px. Definition
That definition matters more than it sounds, because word processors hide it. The named settings in a word processor do not mean what they appear to mean: Butterick reports that Word's Single, 1.5 lines and Double come out at roughly 117, 175 and 233 percent, and his instruction is to set an exact number rather than to use the names.
Now the disagreement, which this manual records rather than resolves:
| Figure | Publisher | What it covers |
|---|---|---|
| At least 1.5 for long text; 1 to 1.35 for headings and one-or-two-line elements | U.S. Web Design System (GSA) | Running text on a screen |
| 1.5 as a value a reader may impose without losing content | WCAG 2.1 SC 1.4.12 | Reflowable web content; images of text and PDF are outside its scope |
| 120 to 145 percent of the point size | Butterick | Print body text |
1.5 and 120 to 145 percent do not agree, and neither source is wrong. The federal figure is for running text on a screen, where a reader may also be resizing the page. Butterick's is for print, which is a fixed object read at a fixed distance. A flyer headline belongs to neither: two large lines set at 1.5 look loose, and the federal figure's own carve-out for one-or-two-line elements says 1 to 1.35.
So the default this manual uses, and the exception that depends on your own piece:
- Default: for a block of running text, set at least 1.5 and do not go below it. This is the figure two of the three sources are compatible with and the one a reader with low vision benefits from.
- Your own exception: for a headline or a two-line block, tighter is normal, and somewhere around 1.1 to 1.2 is where large type usually sits. The federal guidance's own 1-to-1.35 band covers this.
Line length and line spacing turns the number in your menu into the multiple these figures are stated in, and prints both ranges beside your answer rather than picking one.
5. Choosing a typeface, and what the evidence does not say
Here is what this manual's sources support, which is less than most advice claims.
The Nielsen Norman Group's article on legibility says, on typeface, that with today's high-resolution monitors serif type is fine, and that strangely shaped fonts reduce legibility. It recommends a reasonably large default size, letting users change it, high contrast and a plain background. Test it It names no typefaces and gives no sizes, no line spacing and no justification rules, and this manual does not quote it for any of those.
That is close to the whole of the published evidence this manual found on typeface choice. The things that are actually measured are size, spacing and contrast, not serif against sans.
So the working advice is procedural rather than aesthetic:
- Use a typeface with ordinary letterforms. The test is whether you can tell a capital I from a lowercase l from a numeral 1, and a zero from a capital O, at the size you are setting. Test it Print those six characters and look.
- Use one family, with two or three weights. A family has been designed so that its weights sit together, which is a consistency you get for free and would otherwise have to manage.
- Prefer a family that has a bold and an italic you can actually see. Some families bold badly on a cheap printer, and you find out at the copy shop.
- Check the license before you commit to it. The next section, and it is the one that catches people.
"Never use more than two typefaces" has no source this manual could find. What is true is that each additional family is another set of decisions to keep straight, and that the published guidance all assumes a hierarchy a reader can follow. One family with two or three weights is the easiest way to get one, which is a reason, not a rule.
6. What the license of your font allows
A font is software and comes with a license. Four facts cover most of what an ordinary piece runs into.
A typeface design is not copyrightable in the United States; the font software may be. The Copyright Office's Circular 33 says copyright law does not protect typeface or mere variations of typographical ornamentation or lettering, and that the Office cannot register a claim in typeface regardless of whether it is commonly used or unique. Regulation What that means in practice is that the shapes are not the thing you license; the file is.
SIL Open Font License fonts are free to use in your document, with three conditions people trip over. The license permits using, studying, copying, merging, embedding, modifying, redistributing and selling modified and unmodified copies of the font software. What it does not permit is selling a font by itself, or using a reserved font name on a modified version without written permission, and each copy has to carry the copyright notice and the license. Definition The sentence that matters most here: the requirement to stay under the OFL does not apply to any document created using the fonts. A flyer made with an OFL font is not itself under the OFL.
Canva's font software may be used only on Canva. Its content license says you may not install or use the font software on any device other than one running a licensed copy of Canva, or use it other than on Canva or as part of a Canva design exported from Canva. Product-specific So a font you liked in Canva is not a font you can use in Word.
A printer who does not have your font will substitute one. The fix is to send a PDF with the fonts embedded, or to outline the type, which converts the letters to shapes and makes them uneditable. Both printers this manual read ask for one or the other; 4OVER4.COM calls a missing-font substitution the one error that changes your layout.
The full table of sources and what each permits is on What you are allowed to use.
- SIL Open Font License, official text: version 1.1, which has been unchanged since 2007.
- Works Not Protected by Copyright: Circular 33, with the typeface passage and the layout passage, as a PDF.
The rules people repeat, and what is behind them Go deeper
Four claims this subject is full of, with what this manual found.
"Sans serif is more readable" and "serif is more readable." The Nielsen Norman Group says that with today's high-resolution monitors, serif type is fine. That is the whole of what this manual's sources say about the comparison. The differences that are actually measured are size, spacing and contrast. Test it
"Dyslexia fonts help dyslexic readers." Kuster and colleagues, in Annals of Dyslexia in 2018, tested the Dyslexie font against Arial in 170 Dutch children with dyslexia, and then against Arial and Times New Roman in a second experiment with children with and without dyslexia. Children read Dyslexie as fast as Arial with comparable errors, and words set in Dyslexie were not read faster or more accurately. Most children preferred Arial, and preference did not predict reading. The authors' conclusion is that the font neither benefits nor impedes the reading process. The paper's introduction reports a further result that is the useful one here: Marinus and colleagues in 2016 found a small advantage for Dyslexie that vanished once letter spacing was matched. Test it So the change with support behind it is spacing, not the letterforms. The same introduction notes that the British Dyslexia Association recommends a sans serif font and cites no research for it; this manual reports that characterization secondhand and goes no further, because the current guide could not be read.
That is one research group and two experiments with null results, not a meta-analysis. What it does not license is telling somebody their font choice is harming readers; what it does license is spending your effort on size and spacing instead of on a special font.
"Never use more than two fonts." No source. See choosing a typeface for the reason behind the habit.
The system-font rankings. Butterick ranks common system fonts in four grades, from "generally tolerable" down to a grade he calls fatal to your credibility, which includes Arial, Verdana and Comic Sans. The page itself says the rankings blend practical and aesthetic considerations rather than absolute merit, and on his font-recommendations page he states his own position plainly: as a designer of professional fonts, he asks whether he is biased and answers that of course he is. Preference This manual reports that the ranking exists and that it is one designer's taste. It does not adopt it, and it does not tell you that the font on your library's letterhead is fatal to anything.
- Dyslexie font does not benefit reading in children with or without dyslexia: the 2018 paper, open access and readable in full.
- Legibility, Readability, and Comprehension: the Nielsen Norman Group article with the serif sentence.
All caps, centered and justified Go deeper
Three settings people reach for, each with one practitioner's rule and, in one case, a second source that agrees.
All capitals. Butterick's rule is that caps are fine for less than one line of text, and he lists headings, headers, footers, captions, labels, small sizes, letterhead and business cards as the places they belong. He says a paragraph set in all caps is very hard to read and that bold caps are worse, and he asks for letterspacing to be added whenever caps are used, 5 to 12 percent extra. He also says to apply caps as formatting rather than by typing with caps lock, which keeps the real text intact for anyone copying it. The federal plain language guidance agrees from a different direction: it discourages all caps, saying it is considered shouting online and that it makes text harder to read. Convention Two publishers, one of them a federal one, is why this manual treats a short all-caps line as fine and a paragraph as a mistake.
Centered text. Butterick calls centered text overused and says it is fine for short phrases, titles, business card names, letterhead and major headings, but that whole text blocks should not be centered, partly because a centered block is hard to align with anything else on the page. He is explicit that this is opinion. Preference The federal guidance on lists says to use left justification only and never center justification, but that is specifically about lists, and this manual does not stretch it into a rule about body text. Centering genuinely belongs on an invitation, which is one of the few places a whole short piece is centered by convention; Invitations and mailed cards says why.
Justified text. Butterick's rule is that if you justify, you have to turn hyphenation on, and that the extra space goes between words rather than between letters. Preference Justification without hyphenation on a short measure is where the rivers of white space come from, and a flyer column is usually a short measure.
- All caps and Centered text: Butterick's two pages, free, a few hundred words each.
7. See it: a card and a flyer, measured See it
Marguerite Okonkwo sets the retirement supper card. Seventy invitations on 5 by 7 inch cards, in Microsoft Word, read in the hand.
Known. The card is read at about arm's length, so the published ranges apply directly. The body block is six lines: date, time, hall, address, parking, cost and RSVP.
Assumed. That everybody opens the envelope and reads it sitting down. Marguerite's assumption, and a safe one for a mailed card; it would not be safe for a flyer.
Open. Whether the typeface she likes has a bold that survives her home printer's test page. Settled by: one test print at the real size.
Her first setting: 11 point, Word's "Single" line spacing, a full-width text box, centered. One full line came to 38 characters, because a 5-inch card with half-inch margins is narrow. Line spacing at Word's Single is about 117 percent of the point size, which is below both published ranges for a block of text.
What she changed: the point size stayed at 11, the line spacing went to an exact 15 points, which is 1.36 times the size and inside Butterick's print range, and the block stayed centered because this is one of the places centering belongs. The measure stayed at 38 characters, which is below the 45-to-90 range, and she left it there on purpose: the block is six short lines rather than running text, and the range covers running text. That is the kind of decision this chapter is trying to make possible, rather than one that would come out of applying the number blindly.
Yusra Ahmadi sets the story hour flyer. Printed at the branch at 8.5 by 11 inches, in Google Docs. Many of the adults bringing children are grandparents, so large type is a requirement rather than a preference.
Known. The body block is four lines and sits in the middle third of the sheet. The sheet is read from a few feet at the branch noticeboard and from arm's length by somebody who takes one.
Assumed. That large type is what the audience needs, which Yusra has from talking to people at the desk rather than from a document.
Open. What the branch printer does to a lighter weight at this size. Settled by: printing one on the branch printer rather than on hers.
She set the body at 18 point rather than 11, which is well above the print floor and is the point of the exercise. At 18 point across a 7-inch measure she counted 64 characters on a line, inside the 45-to-90 range and close to the 66 the U.S. Web Design System names as a target. Line spacing went to 1.5. The whole block takes more room than a conventional setting, and the thing she took the room from was a paragraph about the library's programs, which was explanation rather than fact.
8. Practice: count a line, measure the spacing Practice
Minimum: one line counted and the line spacing turned into a multiple, both written down. That is the result Start here asks for. Time: about 30 minutes. Materials: your piece in whatever tool you are using, Line length and line spacing, and a printer for one test page.
- Set the body text to the floor first, 16 px on screen or 10 to 12 points in print, and larger if you know your readers need it. Do this before you adjust anything else, because every other number moves when this one does.
- Copy one full line of body text out of the piece and paste it into Line length and line spacing. Full means from the first character to the last character before it wraps.
- If the count is over 90, widen the margin and count again. Only shrink the type if widening the margin is not available to you.
- Find your line spacing as a number. In a word processor, set it to an exact value rather than a named one. Put the type size and the spacing into the second calculator and read the multiple.
- Print one page and look at the six characters: capital I, lowercase l, numeral 1, numeral 0, capital O, and a lowercase a. If any pair is hard to tell apart at your size, change the family.
- Write the size and the spacing on the brief in The piece plan, so the next version of this piece starts from a decision rather than a guess.
The two-alphabet check. Butterick's alternative statement of the measure is two to three alphabets, meaning the lowercase a to z typed twice or three times at your body size. Type it, see how much of a line it fills, and you have a measure check that works in any tool without counting anything.
The printer's bold. Print your bold weight on the machine that will actually print the piece, at the actual size. A library photocopier and an inkjet do different things to a semibold, and the difference shows up on sixty copies rather than on one.
The license note. Put the typeface on the Pictures and fonts sheet in The piece plan with where it came from and what its license requires. It takes a minute now and is unanswerable in six months.
9. Your piece Your piece
10. Check your work Check your work
Criteria
- Is the body text at or above the floor, 16 px on a screen or 10 to 12 points in print?
- Does one full line of body text count between 45 and 90 characters, or can you say why your piece is outside that range on purpose?
- Is the line spacing set as a number you can state, rather than a named setting?
- Is the whole piece in one typeface family?
- Do you know what the font's license allows, and is it on the sheet?
Worked example
Marguerite's card is at 11 point with 15-point spacing, which is 1.36. Against the criteria: the size is inside the print range, the spacing is inside Butterick's range, the family is one family, and the measure is 38 characters, outside the range and deliberately so, because six short lines are not running text. The license question is the one she had not answered, and the answer turned out to matter: the typeface she liked came from Canva, and her card is being set in Word, where that font software is not licensed to run.
Common mistakes
- Shrinking the type to fix a long line. Widen the margin first; it is free.
- Using a word processor's named line spacing and assuming it means what it says. Single is about 117 percent, which is tighter than both published ranges for a block of text.
- Applying the measure to a headline. Three words have no measure, and nothing in the range covers them.
- Typing in caps lock rather than applying caps as formatting. It breaks the real text for anyone who copies it, and it makes the line hard to change later.
- Picking a font in one tool and setting the piece in another. Canva's font software is licensed for Canva, and a system font on your computer may not be on the printer's.
- Treating a published floor as a target. If your readers need large type, 16 px is where you start.
What is still unresolved
This chapter covers running text at arm's length. It does not size anything read from a distance, which is Letter height from distance and Signs. It does not settle how wide the margin should be or where the blocks sit, which is Space and alignment. It does not tell you which typeface to use, because this manual's sources do not support a recommendation, and the one practitioner who does make rankings says on the page that they are his taste. And it gives no legal advice about fonts: it reports what the Copyright Office and two published licenses say, with links, and the point where you need a lawyer is the point where money or a trademark is involved.