Slides that help you, and the handout that does the rest
A short deck whose slides carry a picture and few words, sized for the room it is shown in, and the handout that carries everything the slides do not.
- Start here: the essentials
- Two objects, two jobs
- Which things should be a slide
- Sizing type for the back row
- Contrast in a lit room
- The handout
- The principles, and what sits behind each one
- The slide rules that are opinion
- 16:9, 4:3, PDF, and the room's projector
- What Section 508 asks of a federal deck
- See it: a culvert, a hall and a lobby screen
- Practice: the back-row letter and the handout
- Your piece
- Check your work
- Knowledge check and scenario
Start here Essentials
Four steps. The first one happens before you open any software, and skipping it is what produces a deck of paragraphs.
- Write what you are going to say before you open the slide tool. Prose or notes, in order (two objects, two jobs).
- Make a slide only where a picture would say it better than you can. (which things should be a slide).
- Set the smallest type on any slide so that it reads from the back row. Letter height from distance gives the figure (sizing for the back row).
- Put everything the slides do not carry into the handout. (the handout).
Minimum time: about an hour and a half, plus a visit to the room. Done when: you can give the talk from the slides without reading them aloud, and the handout makes sense to somebody who was not in the room.
1. Two objects, two jobs Understand
A deck is usually asked to do two incompatible things: support a person who is talking, and stand on its own afterward as a record. Those pull in opposite directions, and trying to satisfy both with one object produces slides too dense to look at while you talk and too thin to use a month later.
So the shape this chapter teaches is: make the slides thin and the handout thick, and do not try to make one thing do both.
| The slides | The handout | |
|---|---|---|
| Who is reading | People listening to you | People reading on their own |
| When | While you are speaking | Afterward, or during if they want |
| Read from | The back row | Arm's length |
| Carries | A picture, a few words, a number they have to see | The argument, the figures, the sources, what to do next |
| Length | As few as the talk needs | As long as the content needs |
| Type size | From Letter height from distance | From Type you can read |
A reader will over-read "fewer words on the slide" into a deck nobody can use afterward. The evidence here is about what competes with a speaker while the speaker is speaking. It says nothing against a handout or a written document, and for most of what will not fit on a slide a document is the better object anyway. If somebody asks for the deck afterward and it is seven pictures with four words each, you have not been rigorous; you have sent them something useless. Make both.
The talk itself is a different subject, and a sibling manual covers it: A short presentation, on getting the main message first, numbers an audience can follow, and the questions you expect. For a session where people practice something rather than listen, What you give them and when covers the materials and the run sheet. This chapter makes the slides.
2. Which things should be a slide
Write the talk first. Then go through it and ask, of each part, whether a picture would say it better than you can.
| Earns a slide | Does not |
|---|---|
| A diagram of how something works | A list of your talking points |
| A map or a layout | A sentence you are about to say |
| A photograph of the actual thing | A decorative photograph of a generic thing |
| Two numbers that have to be compared | A table of eleven numbers |
| A before and after | Your agenda, usually |
| A quotation short enough to read in the time it is up | A paragraph |
| One number the room has to hold on to | Your name and title on every slide |
The pattern on the right is the same every time: it is words competing with your words. An audience reading a bulleted list is not listening, and when they finish reading they look back at you having missed the sentence you were saying. The audience's attention is the resource being spent.
The pattern on the left is: it is something you cannot say. Where a culvert is relative to a street. What the room looked like before. The shape of a curve. For those, the picture is the content and your words are the commentary, which is the right way round.
Most explanatory slides are drawings rather than photographs, and the drawing is boxes, lines, arrows and labels. Drawing to explain is how to make one, including the rule that matters most on a slide: the labels go beside the things they label, not in a key.
3. Sizing type for the back row
Nothing this manual found sets a minimum type size for a slide. What it has is the same published rate it uses for signs, applied as arithmetic to a room, and said plainly to be exactly that.
Measure two things in the room:
- The distance from the screen to the back row, in feet. Pace it.
- The height of the projected image, in feet. Measure it if you can get to the wall; estimate it against something you can measure if you cannot.
Put both into Letter height from distance. It gives you a minimum capital height in inches on the screen, and then the number that is actually useful: that height as a fraction of the image height.
The fraction is what you can work with, because you cannot measure inches on a slide canvas. If the answer is that a letter has to be about one seventy-second of the image height, then make a test slide with a single capital letter sized to one seventy-second of the canvas height, and nothing smaller than that letter goes on any slide. Test it That works whatever typeface you use, which a point size does not.
| Back row | Image height | Minimum cap height on screen | As a fraction of the image |
|---|---|---|---|
| 25 ft | 6 ft | 3 in | About 1/24 |
| 35 ft | 6 ft | 4-1/4 in | About 1/17 |
| 45 ft | 6 ft | 5-5/8 in | About 1/13 |
| 45 ft | 10 ft | 5-5/8 in | About 1/21 |
Regulation The rate is Table 703.5.5's, from the 2010 ADA Standards, which govern signs in buildings and facilities covered by the ADA. Applied to a slide it is arithmetic from a published sign table, not a requirement, and this manual says so rather than implying a standard exists.
The practical consequence is the useful part: at 35 feet from a six-foot image, your smallest type is about a seventeenth of the slide height. On a 7.5-inch-tall canvas that is roughly 32 point, and a lot of default slide templates set body text well below it. That is why the default template is the thing to check first.
4. Contrast in a lit room
A projector in a lit room is a different object from your laptop, and the difference runs one way: it loses contrast.
The reason is physical. Physical principle A projector adds light to a screen; it cannot take light away. Your black is whatever the room's ambient light leaves on the screen, so the darker your room, the blacker your black. In a lit council chamber the black is a mid-gray, and every ratio on your deck shrinks toward 1.
What to do about it:
- Measure the pairs you are using in Contrast ratio, and treat the result as the best case rather than the answer. 4.5:1 on your laptop may be well under that on the wall.
- Prefer dark text on a light background for a lit room, because a projector makes light, so a white background is bright and a dark letter is the absence of projected light. In a dark room either polarity works.
- Avoid thin type and thin lines. A hairline weight survives nothing. The formula has no input for stroke weight, which is one of the places the number stops knowing anything.
- Carry nothing by color alone. WCAG's use-of-color criterion applies as much here as anywhere, and a projector's color is less reliable than a screen's.
- Go to the room. Put the deck up, set the lights as they will be, and stand at the back. This is the only test that counts, and it takes ten minutes.
Contrast and color has the thresholds, the measurement and the list of things the measurement does not know.
5. The handout
The handout is a document, not a printout of the slides. Printed slides are a bad document: they have the structure of a talk and none of its content.
What a handout carries:
- The argument in prose, or at least in full sentences. A reader a month later has no speaker.
- The figures, with their sources and dates.
- The diagram from the deck, usually reproduced, because it is the thing people remember and want again.
- What happens next, and who to ask. On a board handout, that is the decision being asked for.
- Your name and one way to reach you.
And the practical constraints, which are the ones people miss until the morning:
- It is read at arm's length, so the type ranges in Type you can read apply: at least 10 to 12 points in print, 45 to 90 characters a line, line spacing at 1.5 for running text.
- It will probably be printed in black and white on an office machine. Run the grayscale check from Contrast and color.
- It has to exist before the meeting if people are going to read it there, which means the printing is part of the schedule rather than an afterthought.
- Count the copies and add some. Seven board members is nine copies: seven, the clerk, and one for you.
The principles, and what sits behind each one Go deeper
The research tradition behind "picture plus spoken words" is the cognitive theory of multimedia learning, associated with Richard Mayer. This manual did not read Mayer's book; it read an open-access observational study of fifty lectures at one UK medical school, published in The Clinical Teacher, which names the principles and gives each a one-line definition. Those definitions, in the paper's own words:
- Multimedia: images and words are better than words alone.
- Modality: images and spoken words are better than images and text.
- Redundancy: images and spoken words are better than images, spoken words and text.
- Coherence: excluding extraneous material is better than including it.
- Signalling: including cues to highlight the organization of material is better than not including them.
- Spatial contiguity: corresponding words should be near rather than far from images.
- Temporal contiguity: words presented alongside images rather than one after the other.
Modality and redundancy are the two that matter most for a deck, and they are the two that say the thing people find hardest to accept: the text on the slide is competing with you.
Three honest caveats.
One effect size, reported secondhand. The paper reports from Mayer's book that for redundancy, five of five tests in system-paced learning gave a combined median Cohen's d of 0.72, against its own benchmarks of 0.5 for medium and 0.8 for large. That is the paper's report of a book this manual did not read, and it is quoted as such rather than as a figure this manual verified.
A boundary condition the paper names: a few words of text is better than none. The principles are not an argument for wordless slides, and the paper merges multimedia, modality and redundancy into what it calls a minimal text principle, noting that this is not a standard term.
The setting is lectures. Fifty lectures at one medical school, observational. A town board meeting is not a lecture and a retirement supper slideshow is not either, and nothing here measures what a deck does to a decision.
- Investigating Death by PowerPoint: the paper, open access.
The slide rules that are opinion Go deeper
Four claims this subject is full of. None of them is malicious and all of them are stated more confidently than their evidence allows.
"One idea per slide." "Six words a line." "A minute a slide." The same paper that names Mayer's principles says that some common slide advice, naming bullet points, one idea per slide and one slide per minute, appears to represent opinion rather than primary research. Preference They are not bad rules of thumb. They are rules of thumb somebody wrote down, and the thing with evidence behind it is the principle set above.
"93 percent of communication is nonverbal." This comes from Albert Mehrabian's work, and his own page states the equation as 7 percent verbal, 38 percent vocal and 55 percent facial, for liking. It also carries his caveat in his own words: the equations were derived from experiments dealing with communications of feelings and attitudes, and "Unless a communicator is talking about their feelings or attitudes, these equations are not applicable." Test it His page does not contain the figure 93 percent; that number is a derivative of his. Somebody explaining a culvert to a town board is not talking about their feelings.
"Match the design to your audience's learning style." Rogowsky, Calhoun and Tallal, in the Journal of Educational Psychology in 2015, reported that Pashler and colleagues in 2008 concluded the learning-styles hypothesis lacks empirical evidence, and that their own study of adult college graduates found no significant link between learning-style preference and comprehension, failing to support the meshing hypothesis. Test it This manual read that through an ERIC record rather than the paper itself, and Pashler and colleagues could not be read directly; both journal routes returned errors. So the honest form is: a well-known review concluded the hypothesis lacks empirical evidence, we are reporting that secondhand, and a later study did not support it either.
"People remember 10 percent of what they read and 50 percent of what they see." No source. It appears nowhere in this manual other than here, to say that it has none.
None of this is a reason to sneer at anybody repeating these. They circulate because they are memorable and because the advice they produce is mostly harmless. The reason to know which is which is that it tells you what to do when a rule conflicts with your actual situation: a rule of thumb yields to the room, and a measured effect is worth keeping.
- Silent Messages: Mehrabian's own page, with the equation and the caveat.
- Rogowsky, Calhoun and Tallal (2015): the ERIC record this manual read.
16:9, 4:3, PDF, and the room's projector Go deeper
The shape. Widescreen, 16:9, is the modern default and matches most screens and projectors made in the last fifteen years. 4:3 is the older shape and still what some fixed installations and older projectors use. A widescreen deck on a 4:3 projector either loses the sides or gains black bars top and bottom, depending on the setting; a 4:3 deck on a widescreen projector sits in the middle with bars at the sides.
Ask the authority The way to settle it is to ask whoever owns the room, and the follow-up question is more useful than the first: ask what the last person's deck looked like. Where you cannot ask, 4:3 is the conservative guess, because its failure is cosmetic bars rather than lost content.
Who you are plugging into. Ask what the connection is, bring the adapter, and if the answer is "we'll put it on a stick", test that the file opens on another machine before the day.
PDF. Exporting to PDF is the most reliable way to get a deck onto somebody else's machine looking the way you built it. What a PDF keeps: the layout, the fonts if you embed them, the images, the page order. What it does not keep: animations, transitions, video, speaker notes unless you choose to export them, and the ability to edit. For a deck that somebody else will project, PDF plus the original file is the belt-and-braces answer.
The tools. Google's Slides page states that anyone with a Google Account can create in Slides, and that some features such as recording and speaker spotlight are only on Workspace plans. Microsoft's page states you get free access to Word, Excel and PowerPoint through Microsoft 365 for the web, with files saved in and shared from OneDrive and 5 GB of storage. Apple's Keynote support pages describe themes, browser editing through Keynote for iCloud, and collaboration, and state no price. Product-specific The fuller comparison, with what each page did and did not say, is on What you can make it in.
What Section 508 asks of a federal deck Go deeper
If you are making a deck for a federal agency, Section 508 applies to it, and it is worth knowing what the official guidance does and does not contain.
The Revised 508 Standards, published by the U.S. Access Board, state that electronic content shall conform to Level A and Level AA success criteria in WCAG 2.0, incorporated by reference. The Board issued the final rule in January 2017 with a correction in January 2018. Regulation
Section508.gov's own page on accessible presentations is a resource hub rather than a checklist. It carries its own caveat that much of its guidance predates the Revised 508 Standards, and it links authoring and testing guides and a training video. This manual records that honestly: it is the official pointer, not a source of rules, and the PowerPoint guide it links would not yield readable text to a fetch.
Note the mismatch, because it catches people who work for public bodies: Section 508 incorporates WCAG 2.0, while the Department of Justice's title II rule for state and local governments requires WCAG 2.1 Level AA. Two federal rules, two versions. The contrast criteria this manual uses are the same in both.
What translates to any deck, federal or not, from the same family of guidance: every slide has a title; reading order is set rather than accidental; every image has a text description; nothing is carried by color alone; contrast meets the thresholds; and a video has captions.
- Accessible Presentations: the GSA hub page, with its own caveat about the age of its guidance.
- Revised 508 Standards and 255 Guidelines: the Access Board's page, with the WCAG 2.0 incorporation.
6. See it: a culvert, a hall and a lobby screen See it
Priya Venkataraman's ten slides for the town board. A twenty-minute item, Tuesday at 7:00 PM in the council chamber, with the back row about thirty-five feet from a six-foot projected image. Seven board members. She builds the deck in Google Slides.
Known. Thirty-five feet and six feet give a minimum cap height of about 4-1/4 inches on screen, which is about one seventeenth of the image height. The room's lights stay on during a board meeting.
Assumed. That the chamber's projector takes a widescreen deck. Priya's assumption. She settles it by asking the clerk what the last presenter's deck looked like.
Open. The diameters of the two pipes, which public works has not yet sent. Settled by: public works. Under these assumptions, her diagram shows the inlet as wider without giving a number, and she says out loud that the figures are coming.
What she built. Ten slides. One is the hand-drawn culvert diagram from Drawing to explain, photographed. Three are photographs of the lot during and after rain. Two are maps. Three carry a single number each. One is the decision she is asking for, in six words.
What the back-row figure changed. Google Slides' default body text in her template was well under a seventeenth of the canvas height. She made a test slide with one capital letter at that fraction, then set every slide so nothing is smaller. Two slides stopped fitting, and both of them turned out to be the ones that were carrying argument rather than picture. Those went into the handout.
The handout. One page, both sides: the argument in prose, the diagram again, the three numbers with their sources, and the decision she is asking the board to make. Nine copies: seven members, the clerk, and one for herself. Printed in the town office in black and white, which is why she ran the grayscale check first.
Marguerite Okonkwo's twelve slides of photographs. At the retirement supper, on the hall's projector, with the back row about forty-five feet from a six-foot image. She uses PowerPoint.
Known. Forty-five feet and six feet give about 5-5/8 inches of cap height on screen, roughly one thirteenth of the image height. Twelve photographs with a caption each.
Assumed. That people at the back want to read the captions. Marguerite's assumption, and this is where it bites: a caption at one thirteenth of the image height is enormous, and twelve enormous captions would dominate twelve photographs.
Open. Whether the hall's projector takes the file from a memory stick or needs a laptop. Settled by: the hall.
What she decided. This is the case where the arithmetic tells you something about the piece rather than about the type. A slideshow of photographs at a supper is not a document and the captions are not load bearing: people are looking at the pictures and talking to each other. So the captions are a year and a place, set at the full back-row size, one short line, and everything else that might have been a caption is said out loud by whoever is introducing the slideshow. Under these assumptions that works; the fact that would change it is whether anybody is expected to follow the captions as a narrative, which she asked the organizers.
Yusra Ahmadi's monthly notice for the lobby screen. A single slide on a screen in a lit library lobby, read at about ten feet by people walking past. She works in Google Slides.
Known. Ten feet at the published rate gives 1-1/8 inch of cap height. The screen is roughly two feet high, so that is about one twenty-first of the image.
Assumed. That the lobby screen shows what her laptop shows. It is older, dimmer and in a brighter room. Test it She settles it by standing in the lobby with the notice up.
Open. Whether the county's template colors are something she may change. Settled by: whoever owns the template.
The contrast finding. The template's heading gray measures 3.03:1 against white, which passes the 3:1 large-scale threshold at the sizes she is using and fails the 4.5:1 threshold for anything smaller. In the lobby, with the lights on and an older screen, the headings were readable and the smaller line beneath was not, which is exactly what the two thresholds predict. Her smaller line moved to the template's near-black, a change inside the template's own palette, and she asked about the heading color rather than changing it.
7. Practice: the back-row letter and the handout Practice
Minimum: one test slide with a capital letter at the back-row fraction, and a one-page handout. That is the result Start here asks for. Time: about two hours, plus a visit to the room. Materials: the room's measurements, Letter height from distance, your slide tool, and a printer.
- Write the talk first, in prose or in notes, in the order you will say it. Before you open the slide tool.
- Mark the places where a picture would say it better than you can. Those are your slides. The count will be lower than you expect.
- Go to the room and measure two numbers: screen to back row, and the height of the projected image.
- Get the fraction from Letter height from distance and make a test slide with one capital letter at that fraction of the canvas height.
- Build the deck with nothing smaller than that letter. Anything that will not fit is a handout item, and noticing which things those are is the useful part.
- Measure your text and background colors in Contrast ratio, and treat the result as the best case.
- Write the handout as a document, not as a printout of the slides. Run the grayscale check on it.
- Go back to the room, put the deck up with the lights as they will be, and stand at the back. Read the smallest thing on each slide out loud.
The talk without slides. Give the talk once with the screen off. What you miss is what has to be a slide; what you do not miss can go. It takes twenty minutes and it is the fastest editor there is.
The month-later read. Give the handout to somebody who was not there and ask them what the decision is and what the evidence was. If they cannot say, the handout is a slide deck with sentences.
The projector rehearsal. Plug in, with your adapter, on the real machine, before the day. The failures are boring and total: the wrong cable, a file that will not open, a font that substituted, a video with no sound.
8. Your piece Your piece
9. Check your work Check your work
Criteria
- Can you give the talk from these slides without reading them aloud?
- Is the smallest thing on any slide at least the back-row fraction of the canvas height?
- Does the handout make sense to somebody who was not in the room?
- Have you looked at the deck in the room, on the room's equipment, with the lights as they will be?
- Is anything on the deck carried by color alone?
Worked example
Priya's deck passes the first criterion because the slides carry pictures and numbers rather than sentences. It passes the second after the test-letter pass, which pushed two slides into the handout. The handout is a document and reads on its own. The fourth criterion is the one she had not met until she went to the chamber, and the thing she found there was that the room's lights put a wash across the lower third of the screen, so her footer line was invisible from the back; the fix was to move the one number that mattered out of the footer.
Common mistakes
- Opening the slide tool first. It produces a deck shaped like a template rather than like a talk.
- Putting your talking points on the slide. They compete with you, which is what the modality and redundancy principles are about.
- Trusting the template's body size. Most default templates set text below the back-row figure for an ordinary room.
- Printing the slides as the handout. It has the structure of a talk and none of its content.
- Checking the deck on a laptop. A lit room takes contrast away and a laptop does not.
- Guessing the projector's shape. Ask what the last person's deck looked like.
- Counting exactly as many handouts as there are people.
What is still unresolved
This chapter makes the slides; it does not teach the talk. A short presentation on Learn Everyday Speaking covers the message, the numbers and the questions, and What you give them and when on Teach a Practical Workshop covers the materials for a session where people practice. No standard this manual found sets a minimum type size for a slide, so the figure here is arithmetic from a published sign table, said as such. The evidence it reports on multimedia principles comes from one observational study reporting a theory, with one effect size quoted secondhand from a book this manual did not read. And nothing here measures what a deck does to a decision; the promise is legibility from the back row and facts that are right.
10. Knowledge check and scenario
Why write the talk before opening the slide tool?
Where does the minimum type size for a slide come from, and what kind of claim is it?
Somebody asks for your deck after the meeting and it is seven pictures with four words each. What went wrong?
(Go deeper) Somebody cites "93 percent of communication is nonverbal" to argue for a wordless deck. What is the answer?
Checklist
Have you just done what this manual teaches? If it is still fresh, we would like to hear about it. We are looking for volunteer guides to add a few short passages from their own experience to this manual. Write to guides@learnthings.online for the details.